View page in desktop
|
Report error
  •   Apple app store icon
  • Google play store icon
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
|
PDPA
|
Site Map
|
Whistleblowing Portal
©2004-2026 Sgcarmart, Singapore. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Car Articles
  • news
  • news Listings
  • Other News
  • Experts say building an undersea tunnel for the HSR will be more complex

    22 Jul 2016

    |

    1,163 views

    The decision to connect Singapore to Malaysia via high-speed rail (HSR) across a bridge, or an undersea tunnel will be made jointly by the both governments.


    In connecting Singapore and Malaysia, will the planned high-speed rail (HSR) run across a bridge spanning the Johor Strait, or will an undersea tunnel have to be built for it? The decision will be made jointly by the governments of both countries. In May, however, the state government of Johor said it hoped an undersea tunnel would be built, reported Malaysian newspapers. But experts believe a bridge is more likely as building an undersea tunnel will be more complex, costly and time-consuming.

    ECAS-EJ Consultants Managing Director Chan Ewe Jin said an undersea tunnel is unlikely and "it's definitely easier to have it on an elevated structure". He boils down the issue to either building the line on the existing Second Link from Tuas, or having a new bridge for it. The tight deadline for completing the rail link may be a factor too.

    Associate Professor Lee Der Horng of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the National University of Singapore said, "I feel a bridge is more likely because an undersea tunnel is more costly and takes more time." Also, with both governments aiming to have the rail line running by 2026, it would be 'easier' to build a bridge than a tunnel, he added. The 2026 target was one of several points of agreement in a memorandum of understanding signed by the two governments on Tuesday.

    In discussing the HSR, a popular comparison is the Eurostar, which runs through a tunnel under the English Channel linking Britain and France. One reason a tunnel was chosen is that the Channel is one of the world's busiest shipping lanes and a bridge may be an obstacle to traffic.

    But the existing 1.9km Tuas Second Link bridge does not pose such a problem, and neither would a new rail bridge, Prof. Lee said. One cross-border rail link that relies on a bridge and undersea tunnel is that between the Danish capital Copenhagen and the Swedish city Malmo. The trains reach speeds of up to 200km/h. The rail line runs along the Oresund bridge from the Swedish coast to an island, then finishes the last one third of the crossing via an undersea tunnel.
    24.4k

    Tags

    high-speed rail hsr connect singapore to malaysia undersea tunnel tuas second link second link tuas

    AllReviewsNewsAdviceFeaturesVideos
    • Home
    • Car Articles
    • news
    • news Listings
    • Other News

    Experts say building an undersea tunnel for the HSR will be more complex

    22 Jul 2016

    |

    1,163 views

    The decision to connect Singapore to Malaysia via high-speed rail (HSR) across a bridge, or an undersea tunnel will be made jointly by the both governments.


    In connecting Singapore and Malaysia, will the planned high-speed rail (HSR) run across a bridge spanning the Johor Strait, or will an undersea tunnel have to be built for it? The decision will be made jointly by the governments of both countries. In May, however, the state government of Johor said it hoped an undersea tunnel would be built, reported Malaysian newspapers. But experts believe a bridge is more likely as building an undersea tunnel will be more complex, costly and time-consuming.

    ECAS-EJ Consultants Managing Director Chan Ewe Jin said an undersea tunnel is unlikely and "it's definitely easier to have it on an elevated structure". He boils down the issue to either building the line on the existing Second Link from Tuas, or having a new bridge for it. The tight deadline for completing the rail link may be a factor too.

    Associate Professor Lee Der Horng of the Department of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the National University of Singapore said, "I feel a bridge is more likely because an undersea tunnel is more costly and takes more time." Also, with both governments aiming to have the rail line running by 2026, it would be 'easier' to build a bridge than a tunnel, he added. The 2026 target was one of several points of agreement in a memorandum of understanding signed by the two governments on Tuesday.

    In discussing the HSR, a popular comparison is the Eurostar, which runs through a tunnel under the English Channel linking Britain and France. One reason a tunnel was chosen is that the Channel is one of the world's busiest shipping lanes and a bridge may be an obstacle to traffic.

    But the existing 1.9km Tuas Second Link bridge does not pose such a problem, and neither would a new rail bridge, Prof. Lee said. One cross-border rail link that relies on a bridge and undersea tunnel is that between the Danish capital Copenhagen and the Swedish city Malmo. The trains reach speeds of up to 200km/h. The rail line runs along the Oresund bridge from the Swedish coast to an island, then finishes the last one third of the crossing via an undersea tunnel.
    24.4k

    Tags

    high-speed rail hsr connect singapore to malaysia undersea tunnel tuas second link second link tuas

    Newsletter

    Be Notified On The Latest News

    Newsletter

    Be Notified On The Latest News

    Latest COE Prices

    November 2026 | 1st BIDDING
    NEXT TENDER: 18 Nov 2026
    CAT A
    $139,001
    CAT B
    $132,334
    CAT C
    $92,000
    CAT E
    $135,998
    View Full Results

    Latest COE Prices

    November 2026 | 1st BIDDING
    NEXT TENDER: 18 Nov 2026
    CAT A
    $139,001
    CAT B
    $132,334
    CAT C
    $92,000
    CAT E
    $135,998
    View Full Results

    You May Also Like

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Cars of 2026

    Cars of 2026

    You May Also Like

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Cars of 2026

    Cars of 2026

    Related Articles

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail terminated as both sides fail to reach agreement

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail terminated as both sides fail to reach agreement

    Europeans bidding for KL-Singapore High-Speed Rail

    Europeans bidding for KL-Singapore High-Speed Rail

    LTA forms subsidiary to take charge of Singapore end of high-speed rail project

    LTA forms subsidiary to take charge of Singapore end of high-speed rail project

    Discussions on ticketing and fare collection system for SG-KL HSR in October

    Discussions on ticketing and fare collection system for SG-KL HSR in October

    Briefing for firms interested in high speed rail assets company tender in July

    Briefing for firms interested in high speed rail assets company tender in July

    Six consultancy contracts awarded for High-Speed Rail

    Six consultancy contracts awarded for High-Speed Rail

    Government to acquire Raffles Country Club for Singapore-KL High Speed Rail

    Government to acquire Raffles Country Club for Singapore-KL High Speed Rail

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail land acquisition expected late next year

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail land acquisition expected late next year

    Related Articles

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail terminated as both sides fail to reach agreement

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail terminated as both sides fail to reach agreement

    Europeans bidding for KL-Singapore High-Speed Rail

    Europeans bidding for KL-Singapore High-Speed Rail

    LTA forms subsidiary to take charge of Singapore end of high-speed rail project

    LTA forms subsidiary to take charge of Singapore end of high-speed rail project

    Discussions on ticketing and fare collection system for SG-KL HSR in October

    Discussions on ticketing and fare collection system for SG-KL HSR in October

    Briefing for firms interested in high speed rail assets company tender in July

    Briefing for firms interested in high speed rail assets company tender in July

    Six consultancy contracts awarded for High-Speed Rail

    Six consultancy contracts awarded for High-Speed Rail

    Government to acquire Raffles Country Club for Singapore-KL High Speed Rail

    Government to acquire Raffles Country Club for Singapore-KL High Speed Rail

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail land acquisition expected late next year

    KL-Singapore High Speed Rail land acquisition expected late next year