View page in desktop
|
Report error
  •   Apple app store icon
  • Google play store icon
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
|
PDPA
|
Site Map
|
Whistleblowing Portal
©2004-2026 Sgcarmart, Singapore. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Car Articles
  • advice
  • advice Listings
  • Miscellaneous Advice

Are women really bad drivers?

09 Oct 2007

|

44,836 views

Yes, we've all heard it before. Women can't drive for nuts. But just how accurate is this notion? Hear our female correspondent weigh in.

I jammed hard on my brakes. The green Honda Civic had suddenly cut into my lane without signaling, and I was forced to react quickly to avoid a collision. "Must be a woman," my male passenger stated matter-of-factly.

Yes, we've all heard it before. Women can't park. They drive on the rightmost lane of the expressway at 60km/h. They can't tell left from right. They put on their makeup while driving. This is the typical image of the female driver that is often bandied about, but how accurate is it?

5 out of 10 drivers polled in an informal survey felt that women are generally bad drivers, while the remainder disagreed. Interestingly, the number of women and men were equally split on either side.

Common complaints about women drivers include driving too slowly, being unobservant and careless, and having slow reaction times. "Women are too tentative when they change lanes," Shawn, 25, says, "slow, just a bit unaware on the road, causing inconvenience, a bit blur blur." Many feel that women have poorer navigation skills and do not judge distances as well as men.

Scientific evidence seems to support this. Studies conducted by scientists from the University of Giessen, Germany, have shown that women achieved lower scores in tests that measured their spatial skills, as compared to their male counterparts. This may be caused by a lack of testosterone in the womb, which they say may adversely affect spatial ability. Such spatial ability includes the ability to assess spaces and judge distances, skills which are essential to driving.

Yet statistically speaking, women are less prone to getting into accidents than men are. Data from the U.S. Department of Transportation's Fatality Analysis Reporting System shows that about 73% of all people killed in car accidents are male, almost 3 times the number of women. Even taking into account driving distances (which are longer for men than for women on average), the number of men killed in car accidents is 70% higher than that of women.

This could be due to the fact that men have a higher tendency to engage in aggressive, risk-taking behaviour, and tend to be less patient than women. Statistics from research conducted at the University of Hawaii show that men are more likely to exceed the speed limit than women and change lanes without signaling. They are also twice as likely to make illegal turns and three times as likely to cut other drivers off. Alcohol use may be another contributing factor. In 2003, for example, 27% of the male drivers in fatal crashes had been drinking, whereas only 12.5% of the female drivers had done so.

Even Shawn concedes that "guys also cause inconvenience on the roads sometimes, usually because they don't care." In fact, the conventional notion that men are better drivers may actually cause them to overestimate their supposedly superior spatial skills, ironically disproving that very notion. "I think it's just a really stale stereotype," says Delphia, 22, "I look around at the girls I know™ they're all steady drivers."

Ultimately, it is difficult to generalize. Men and women each have different skill sets and personality traits that all contribute to their behaviour on the roads. Perhaps Jiaxiang, 24, sums it up best when he says, "I've seen plenty of bad female drivers, but the best driver I know is my mom."
AllReviewsNewsAdviceFeaturesVideos
  • Home
  • Car Articles
  • advice
  • advice Listings
  • Miscellaneous Advice

Are women really bad drivers?

09 Oct 2007

|

44,836 views

Yes, we've all heard it before. Women can't drive for nuts. But just how accurate is this notion? Hear our female correspondent weigh in.

I jammed hard on my brakes. The green Honda Civic had suddenly cut into my lane without signaling, and I was forced to react quickly to avoid a collision. "Must be a woman," my male passenger stated matter-of-factly.

Yes, we've all heard it before. Women can't park. They drive on the rightmost lane of the expressway at 60km/h. They can't tell left from right. They put on their makeup while driving. This is the typical image of the female driver that is often bandied about, but how accurate is it?

5 out of 10 drivers polled in an informal survey felt that women are generally bad drivers, while the remainder disagreed. Interestingly, the number of women and men were equally split on either side.

Common complaints about women drivers include driving too slowly, being unobservant and careless, and having slow reaction times. "Women are too tentative when they change lanes," Shawn, 25, says, "slow, just a bit unaware on the road, causing inconvenience, a bit blur blur." Many feel that women have poorer navigation skills and do not judge distances as well as men.

Scientific evidence seems to support this. Studies conducted by scientists from the University of Giessen, Germany, have shown that women achieved lower scores in tests that measured their spatial skills, as compared to their male counterparts. This may be caused by a lack of testosterone in the womb, which they say may adversely affect spatial ability. Such spatial ability includes the ability to assess spaces and judge distances, skills which are essential to driving.

Yet statistically speaking, women are less prone to getting into accidents than men are. Data from the U.S. Department of Transportation's Fatality Analysis Reporting System shows that about 73% of all people killed in car accidents are male, almost 3 times the number of women. Even taking into account driving distances (which are longer for men than for women on average), the number of men killed in car accidents is 70% higher than that of women.

This could be due to the fact that men have a higher tendency to engage in aggressive, risk-taking behaviour, and tend to be less patient than women. Statistics from research conducted at the University of Hawaii show that men are more likely to exceed the speed limit than women and change lanes without signaling. They are also twice as likely to make illegal turns and three times as likely to cut other drivers off. Alcohol use may be another contributing factor. In 2003, for example, 27% of the male drivers in fatal crashes had been drinking, whereas only 12.5% of the female drivers had done so.

Even Shawn concedes that "guys also cause inconvenience on the roads sometimes, usually because they don't care." In fact, the conventional notion that men are better drivers may actually cause them to overestimate their supposedly superior spatial skills, ironically disproving that very notion. "I think it's just a really stale stereotype," says Delphia, 22, "I look around at the girls I know™ they're all steady drivers."

Ultimately, it is difficult to generalize. Men and women each have different skill sets and personality traits that all contribute to their behaviour on the roads. Perhaps Jiaxiang, 24, sums it up best when he says, "I've seen plenty of bad female drivers, but the best driver I know is my mom."
Freelancer
Text and photos by Sylvia Tee
I've been writing about cars for many years, and I wonder if I'm getting any better at it.
24.4k

Tags

bad women drivers bad woman driver women drivers woman driver bad driving women bad driving bad driver

Freelancer
Text and photos by Sylvia Tee
I've been writing about cars for many years, and I wonder if I'm getting any better at it.
24.4k

Tags

bad women drivers bad woman driver women drivers woman driver bad driving women bad driving bad driver

All Advice Categories

Car BuyingCar SellingCar OwnershipCar TechnicalCar MaintenanceMiscellaneous

All Advice Categories

Car BuyingCar SellingCar OwnershipCar TechnicalCar MaintenanceMiscellaneous

Related Motor Directory Categories

    Audio System - In Car EntertainmentKeys & RemoteCar Towing & Roadside AssistanceDecals, Stickers & Number PlatesCar MatsMobile Battery & Tyre Replacement

Related Motor Directory Categories

    Audio System - In Car EntertainmentKeys & RemoteCar Towing & Roadside AssistanceDecals, Stickers & Number PlatesCar MatsMobile Battery & Tyre Replacement

Related Articles

Long miles in a small car can be easy

Long miles in a small car can be easy

Recommended Car Mats Worth Considering for Your Car

Recommended Car Mats Worth Considering for Your Car

6 Car Upgrades Worth the Money for a Better Daily Drive

6 Car Upgrades Worth the Money for a Better Daily Drive

Engine Oil Options to Suit Your Driving Needs

Engine Oil Options to Suit Your Driving Needs

The Truth About Old DOT Tyres: Myth or Fact?

The Truth About Old DOT Tyres: Myth or Fact?

Related Articles

Long miles in a small car can be easy

Long miles in a small car can be easy

Recommended Car Mats Worth Considering for Your Car

Recommended Car Mats Worth Considering for Your Car

6 Car Upgrades Worth the Money for a Better Daily Drive

6 Car Upgrades Worth the Money for a Better Daily Drive

Engine Oil Options to Suit Your Driving Needs

Engine Oil Options to Suit Your Driving Needs

The Truth About Old DOT Tyres: Myth or Fact?

The Truth About Old DOT Tyres: Myth or Fact?

You May Also Like

Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

Cars of 2026

Cars of 2026

Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

Hongqi Singapore opens its showroom doors

Hongqi Singapore opens its showroom doors

Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

BYD Atto 3 Evo Facelift Review

BYD Atto 3 Evo Facelift Review

You May Also Like

Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

Cars of 2026

Cars of 2026

Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

Hongqi Singapore opens its showroom doors

Hongqi Singapore opens its showroom doors

Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

BYD Atto 3 Evo Facelift Review

BYD Atto 3 Evo Facelift Review