Verdict
It might be indicative of the automotive landscape of 2025, but the five of the seven of the long list of cars considered for this year's Editorial Pick were all electric (of which two are large MPVs), and not a single performance-oriented car even made the cut.
And while performance cars may still hold a special place enthusiasts hearts, our Editorial Pick must also reflect the preferences and sensibilities of the wider car-buying population – after all, few people likely want to (or can afford) to live with the severe compromises of a hard-riding two-door sports car.
Which brings us to this year's Editorial Pick – the MGS5. A car that fits neatly in two of the most high-demand segments right now. One, it's an SUV. And two, it's electric.
The MGS5 stood out not by shouting the loudest, but by getting the fundamentals right. It has got a clean and contemporary design, with just a hint of sportiness, that feels cohesive to the personality of the car.
Inside, we were drawn to the user-friendliness of the cabin and all of its controls. With many brands going down the fully-digital route, we appreciated that physical controls for regularly used functions were still present. Ditto for the infotainment system – it's one of the least complicated ones we've experience, and genuinely pleasant and easy-to-use. Optimal packaging on its EV package also means that rear passengers have generous amounts of space.
On the road, the most distinguishing characteristic of the MGS5 is its rear-wheel drive layout. While the 99kW output is modest, 250Nm of torque makes for easy-enough acceleration. But that RWD layout comes to the fore while driving, with the car feeling sharp eager to tuck its nose into bends. That added agility is much welcome in a segment that typically does not prioritise the driver. It also makes tackling tigher spaces easier, with the car having a smaller turning radius.
Ultimately, driving this choice was the question of accessibility. The MGS5 delivers good-enough range from a modest size battery, has solid charging credentials, and makes a compelling case for electric mobility thanks to competitive pricing. And it is the combination, usability and modern EV appeal that makes it our Editorial Pick for this year.