View page in desktop
|
Report error
  •   Apple app store icon
  • Google play store icon
Terms of Service
|
Privacy Policy
|
PDPA
|
Site Map
|
Whistleblowing Portal
©2004-2026 Sgcarmart, Singapore. All rights reserved.
  • Home
  • Car Articles
  • news
  • news Listings
  • Other News
  • Uber's appeal over anti-competitive Grab merger dismissed, $6.58m fine upheld

    14 Jan 2021

    |

    1,231 views

    Ride-hailing firm Uber will have to pay a $6.58 million penalty after its appeal against a 2018 decision that it had breached competition laws was dismissed.


    Ride-hailing firm Uber will have to pay a $6.58 million penalty after its appeal against a 2018 decision that it had breached competition laws here was dismissed last month.

    An appeal board chaired by Senior Counsel Andre Yeap upheld the fine and other measures imposed by the Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS), which had found that Grab and Uber's merger in March 2018 was anti-competitive.

    An appeal board upheld the fine and other measures imposed by the CCCS which determined that Grab and Uber's merger was anti-competitive
    The board, which made its decision on 29 December 2020, also ordered Uber to pay CCCS's costs for the appeal. In its decision published on 13 January 2021, the board said it was persuaded that Grab and Uber must have been aware that their merger would have restricted competition.

    Uber had sold its South-East Asian business to Grab for a 27.5% stake in Grab. Before then, the firms had a combined market share that was more than five times the next biggest player, ComfortDelGro, and the deal would have crossed thresholds indicating potential competition concerns, the appeal board said.

    Uber had sought to set aside the CCCS's 2018 verdict or reduce the penalty imposed. After a six-month investigation, the commission ruled in September 2018 that the Grab-Uber deal reduced market competition and resulted in Grab getting an 80% share of Singapore's ride-hailing market, up from 50% previously.

    Noting then that it was too late to unwind the deal, the commission spelt out a series of measures to cushion the impact on commuters, drivers and potential competitors. This included requiring Grab to remove exclusivity arrangements with taxi fleets and drivers, as well as maintain its pre-merger pricing algorithm and driver commission rates.
    The CCCS determined the merger of Grab and Uber would result in Grab getting a near-monopoly 80% share of the ride-hailing market
    Grab did not appeal and paid a $6.4 million fine. But Uber fought the verdict as 'a matter of principle'. In its submissions, the firm argued that it did not flout anti-competition laws intentionally or negligently, nor did the merger lead to a substantial lessening of competition, especially in light of Gojek's entry into the market later that year.

    But the appeal board agreed with the CCCS, noting that without the measures imposed, the Grab-Uber deal would have allowed Grab to request Uber not to sell its car rental arm Lion City Rentals to another party. Grab would also have had the ability and incentive to reinforce its position by entering into exclusivity arrangements.

    The board said Gojek's entry was not of sufficient scope to constrain Grab, noting that Grab had deeper pockets and would have been able to invest more heavily in order to maintain its competitive advantage post-merger, posing a significant barrier to entry.

    The board also pointed to internal documents and funding estimates from both Uber and Grab indicating that they had expected the deal to increase Grab's ability to increase prices. This happened in the wake of the merger and even after Gojek's entry.

    Uber has until 26 January 2021 to appeal the verdict, otherwise it must pay the fine and the legal fees of the CCCS
    There had also been a significant reduction in promotions and incentives, and post-merger data did not show that Gojek's entry restored competition to pre-merger levels. In a statement, CCCS Chief Executive Sia Aik Kor said the board's decision reinforced the message that mergers that substantially lessen competition in Singapore are prohibited.

    She said, "Singapore's voluntary notification merger regime aims to strike a balance between safeguarding competition and being pro-business... Should CCCS have reasonable grounds to suspect that an anti-competitive merger has been completed or is anticipated, it is empowered to investigate and take appropriate enforcement action."

    Uber has until 26 January 2021 to appeal to the High Court on specific points of law or the amount it needs to pay. The Straits Times has contacted the firm for comment.
    24.4k

    Tags

    singapore uber grab merger anti competitive dismissed fine appeal dismissed

    AllReviewsNewsAdviceFeaturesVideos
    • Home
    • Car Articles
    • news
    • news Listings
    • Other News

    Uber's appeal over anti-competitive Grab merger dismissed, $6.58m fine upheld

    14 Jan 2021

    |

    1,231 views

    Ride-hailing firm Uber will have to pay a $6.58 million penalty after its appeal against a 2018 decision that it had breached competition laws was dismissed.


    Ride-hailing firm Uber will have to pay a $6.58 million penalty after its appeal against a 2018 decision that it had breached competition laws here was dismissed last month.

    An appeal board chaired by Senior Counsel Andre Yeap upheld the fine and other measures imposed by the Competition and Consumer Commission of Singapore (CCCS), which had found that Grab and Uber's merger in March 2018 was anti-competitive.

    An appeal board upheld the fine and other measures imposed by the CCCS which determined that Grab and Uber's merger was anti-competitive
    The board, which made its decision on 29 December 2020, also ordered Uber to pay CCCS's costs for the appeal. In its decision published on 13 January 2021, the board said it was persuaded that Grab and Uber must have been aware that their merger would have restricted competition.

    Uber had sold its South-East Asian business to Grab for a 27.5% stake in Grab. Before then, the firms had a combined market share that was more than five times the next biggest player, ComfortDelGro, and the deal would have crossed thresholds indicating potential competition concerns, the appeal board said.

    Uber had sought to set aside the CCCS's 2018 verdict or reduce the penalty imposed. After a six-month investigation, the commission ruled in September 2018 that the Grab-Uber deal reduced market competition and resulted in Grab getting an 80% share of Singapore's ride-hailing market, up from 50% previously.

    Noting then that it was too late to unwind the deal, the commission spelt out a series of measures to cushion the impact on commuters, drivers and potential competitors. This included requiring Grab to remove exclusivity arrangements with taxi fleets and drivers, as well as maintain its pre-merger pricing algorithm and driver commission rates.
    The CCCS determined the merger of Grab and Uber would result in Grab getting a near-monopoly 80% share of the ride-hailing market
    Grab did not appeal and paid a $6.4 million fine. But Uber fought the verdict as 'a matter of principle'. In its submissions, the firm argued that it did not flout anti-competition laws intentionally or negligently, nor did the merger lead to a substantial lessening of competition, especially in light of Gojek's entry into the market later that year.

    But the appeal board agreed with the CCCS, noting that without the measures imposed, the Grab-Uber deal would have allowed Grab to request Uber not to sell its car rental arm Lion City Rentals to another party. Grab would also have had the ability and incentive to reinforce its position by entering into exclusivity arrangements.

    The board said Gojek's entry was not of sufficient scope to constrain Grab, noting that Grab had deeper pockets and would have been able to invest more heavily in order to maintain its competitive advantage post-merger, posing a significant barrier to entry.

    The board also pointed to internal documents and funding estimates from both Uber and Grab indicating that they had expected the deal to increase Grab's ability to increase prices. This happened in the wake of the merger and even after Gojek's entry.

    Uber has until 26 January 2021 to appeal the verdict, otherwise it must pay the fine and the legal fees of the CCCS
    There had also been a significant reduction in promotions and incentives, and post-merger data did not show that Gojek's entry restored competition to pre-merger levels. In a statement, CCCS Chief Executive Sia Aik Kor said the board's decision reinforced the message that mergers that substantially lessen competition in Singapore are prohibited.

    She said, "Singapore's voluntary notification merger regime aims to strike a balance between safeguarding competition and being pro-business... Should CCCS have reasonable grounds to suspect that an anti-competitive merger has been completed or is anticipated, it is empowered to investigate and take appropriate enforcement action."

    Uber has until 26 January 2021 to appeal to the High Court on specific points of law or the amount it needs to pay. The Straits Times has contacted the firm for comment.
    24.4k

    Tags

    singapore uber grab merger anti competitive dismissed fine appeal dismissed

    Newsletter

    Be Notified On The Latest News

    Newsletter

    Be Notified On The Latest News

    Latest COE Prices

    November 2026 | 1st BIDDING
    NEXT TENDER: 18 Nov 2026
    CAT A
    $139,001
    CAT B
    $132,334
    CAT C
    $92,000
    CAT E
    $135,998
    View Full Results

    Latest COE Prices

    November 2026 | 1st BIDDING
    NEXT TENDER: 18 Nov 2026
    CAT A
    $139,001
    CAT B
    $132,334
    CAT C
    $92,000
    CAT E
    $135,998
    View Full Results

    You May Also Like

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Cars of 2026

    Cars of 2026

    You May Also Like

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    Sgcarmart Explores: Bras Basah!

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    New cars are safer: Opt for one when you can

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Leapmotor B10: The electric SUV focused on what matters

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    Tesla Model 3 Facelift Review

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The rise of PHEVs: A closer look at the numbers

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    The all new XPENG Mona L03 is one smart coupe SUV

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Lexus ES350h Hybrid Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    Multi-Pathway approach: Toyota was always right

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Mercedes-Benz GLC Electric Review

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Sgcarmart Explores: East Coast Park!

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    The 5 main things you must know about the XPENG L03

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Don't get yourself trapped in your high-tech EV

    Cars of 2026

    Cars of 2026

    Related Articles

    BYD launches the new Seal 7 DM-i in Singapore

    BYD launches the new Seal 7 DM-i in Singapore

    XPENG L03 launches in Singapore from $202,999

    XPENG L03 launches in Singapore from $202,999

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Lambency Detailing introduces SG's 1st AI-assisted car wash

    Lambency Detailing introduces SG's 1st AI-assisted car wash

    BYD by Sime Motors heads to Bukit Panjang Plaza

    BYD by Sime Motors heads to Bukit Panjang Plaza

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Sealion 7 Extended Range Facelift Review

    BYD Sealion 7 Extended Range Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Related Articles

    BYD launches the new Seal 7 DM-i in Singapore

    BYD launches the new Seal 7 DM-i in Singapore

    XPENG L03 launches in Singapore from $202,999

    XPENG L03 launches in Singapore from $202,999

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Li Auto confirms Singapore entry with Wearnes

    Lambency Detailing introduces SG's 1st AI-assisted car wash

    Lambency Detailing introduces SG's 1st AI-assisted car wash

    BYD by Sime Motors heads to Bukit Panjang Plaza

    BYD by Sime Motors heads to Bukit Panjang Plaza

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Seal 7 DM-i Review

    BYD Sealion 7 Extended Range Facelift Review

    BYD Sealion 7 Extended Range Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review

    Kia Niro Hybrid Facelift Review