Viewed : 15,047 times
What they don't tell you: Your pop and bang map isn't anti-lag and it isn't doing anything for your car's performance
Pop and bang, or crackle tune - call it what you like, but it doesn't add to the performance of your car. Oh, and it doesn't sound good to most people either.
Category: Car Technical Advice
Modern day technology has made fettling with cars much easier and more accessible than before. With an Engine Control Unit (ECU) taking care of things such as the air-fuel ratio and the ignition timing, there's no need to meddle with things such as the jetting of a carburettor or adjusting the distributor - everything can be adjusted to the finest detail with the use of a computer and the appropriate software and/or hardware.
It didn't take long for people to realise that one could meddle with the ECU settings to get a car to produce loud pop and bang noises, and even flames from the exhaust with relative ease. While many have likened it to the anti-lag system found on Rally cars, is it really the same thing?
What is 'pop and bang' and how is it achieved
'Pop and bang', 'crackle tune', 'popcorn tune' and flame maps are just some terms used to describe the fettling of a car's ECU to create loud pops and even flames from the exhaust of the car when one gets off the accelerator.
The loud noises and flames occur when fuel enters the hot exhaust system and ignites. Normally, such a phenomenon will almost never happen as the manufacturers will design the fuel system to stop injecting fuel when you get off the throttle.
One way to get the car to pop and bang would be to retard the ignition timing during deceleration by tweaking the ECU. By doing so, the ignition event is delayed so much that the air and fuel mixture never gets ignited within the cylinder. Instead, it eventually combusts within the exhaust manifold, producing the loud noise.
Another method would be to meddle with the fuel overrun settings within the ECU, which effectively means that the injectors are still dumping fuel into the engine during deceleration. Likewise, the excess fuel will enter the exhaust system and combust within. With this method, you can even achieve large flames from the exhaust due to the sheer amount of fuel that gets dumped into the exhaust system.
"My tuner told me it is a form of anti-lag"
Tuners and people who love pop and bang maps often tout it as anti-lag that will drastically improve the performance of the car. While the loud noises might sound similar to the ones that WRC Rally cars produce, they aren't exactly the same thing.
The anti-lag systems found in WRC rally cars and other purpose-built race cars are specially engineered with dedicated systems that introduce fresh air directly into the exhaust manifold.
This results in a powerful combustion event (in the exhaust manifold), which will quickly spool the turbo up and reduce turbo lag before the driver gets back on the throttle, or in between gears. And if you think it sounds harmful to the engine, it actually is. A true anti-lag system puts plenty of stress on components such as the engine, the turbo and the exhaust manifold.
Meanwhile, the typical pop and bang ECU tune simply isn't substantial enough to work as an anti-lag setup. Furthermore, there are plenty of naturally aspirated car owners who have been fooled into pop and bang tunes, which definitely don't do anything to the performance at all.
But there's no harm done right?
While your garden-variety pop and bang ECU tune isn't anywhere near as harsh as the WRC anti-lag systems, you are still putting undue stress on your engine's exhaust manifold and the exhaust valves as well as other components. As such, you do risk damaging the components of your engine with a pop and bang tune, and unlike a full-blown Anti-Lag System, there isn't even any substantial performance benefits to be reaped.
Aside from the potentially costly damage that you can do to your car, the larger issue is the nuisance that you'll create. The issue is aggravated especially if you do not have the self-restraint to act in a civilised manner while driving past housing areas during wee hours. Furthermore, the widely shared opinion, even among car enthusiasts, is that pop and bang noises simply don't sound good.
So, do your car and everyone else a favour, stop wasting your money on pop and bang tunes to make a fool out of yourself.
Here are some other articles that you might be interested in:
What they don't tell you: A loud exhaust doesn't always make more power
What they don't tell you: An extreme-performance tyre might not be the best choice for everyone
What they don't tell you: Lowering your car with coilovers isn't going to magically perfect its handling
What they don't tell you: The downsides of installing a big brake kit
Mythbusted: Does a faster car always consume more fuel?